Almost a perfect score! This is my second M's Prospector Sweater and I'm sure it will get lot's of wear. The synthetic material is the perfect middle weight for warmth outside, but not overheating inside. The shoulder and elbow patches are as stylish as they are useful. My only negative is sizing: it's just about one full size too big. I am 5'8" and an athletic 165 lbs, and I was swimming in the medium. Small is a perfect fit. Recommended, just check your size!