Here are my thoughts after receiving the shirt:
1. The quality of this shirt seems excellent
2. The color was exactly as seen in pictures
3. The fit in the sleeves and width was great, but the length was just short enough that it bugged me (I own the Canadian insulated shirt in a large, and it fits PERFECT. I wear it everyday and have recommended it to other who have also purchased it). Unfortunately, the large in the Canadian overshirt fit good everywhere, except for length
4. The material seems to be a really good quality and weight, but you need to have a long sleeve shirt under this if you are wearing it. I tried this shirt on with just a short sleeve shirt under and it was itchy against the skin.
Overall, this seems like a great shirt, but the length in the body and the itchiness of the material made me decide to return it.